*** pre orders are now closed ***

any orders placed now will be put on a waitlist and you will be notified if orders can be fulfilled.

due to limited supply of ingredients, some of our flavors will not be available at events. thank you for understanding and we will update our website if there are any changes.

upcoming events

sunday, 11/01/26
maui high School holiday craft fair
mhs gym
9:00a - 2:00p

sunday, 11/22/26
ben franklin winter craft fair
qkc parking garage
9:00a - 3:00p

Saturday 11/28/26
hometown holiday makeke 2026
qkc - former cvs location
10:00a - 4:00p

Saturday, 12/05/26
maui county fcu holiday craft fair
mcfcu wailuku 224 kehalani village drive
9:00a - 1:00p

We bake, you smile.

We love making people smile (figuratively and literally—we are both dental professionals). Our sweet tooth brought us together to create our cookie company, and now we dream up creative new combos to satisfy your cravings.

winter menu

A hand dunking a cookie into milk. Maui Sugar Mamas cookie bag in the background.

Cookies on a chopping board and bags of cookies

Call Us ‘Sugar Mamas’

Leanne & Ana

Our story

Unique Flavors

Hand-Scooped

illustration of steaming cookies on a tray

Baked Fresh

Sealed

Specialty Products

Winter Flavors

A Sweet Cuppa Jojo

Hot chocolate & cappuccino - large cookie

Nothing warms you up better than hot chocolate on a cold winter day. This cookie will warm up your heart and soul, extra chocolatey and full of flavor.

Alice in Sugarland

Red velvet - bite size - cookie

This flavor is a tribute to the Original Maui Sugar Mama, Mama Alice. She baked her heart out from chiffon cakes, to chiffon pumpkin pies, to cinnamon rolls and more. Red Velvet was a special request for dadʻs birthday on Dec 25th. Thank you mom for being our inspiration!

Merry Mint

Dark Chocolate mint - bite size cookie

Our dark chocolate mint melts in your mouth. For those chocolate mint lovers, this cookie has just the right amount of mint which is refreshing and wakes up your taste buds.